How to Get Job Candidates to Drop the Canned Answers and Open Up

Carol Quinn is convinced there’s a widespread conspiracy afoot
in the world of job interviewing.

Image source:

Many interviewers’ questions are so benign, she says—so
accommodating—that there must be a posse of job seekers out there writing these
queries themselves.

Quinn is joking, of course, but she made her point during a
concurrent session at the Society for Human Resource Management’s (SHRM’s)
Talent Management Conference & Exposition. And her point is this: Because
too many hiring managers lack formal training on conducting job interviews,
applicants can easily conceal a lack of motivation or passion that might
prevent them from succeeding at a job.

“The job seeker’s purpose is to get a job offer,”
Quinn told conference attendees. She is CEO of Conyers, Ga.-based Hire
Authority, which helps companies improve their interviewing and hiring.
“They accentuate the positive, minimize the negative. They sell, sell,
sell. Job candidates have become proficient at how to conduct an interview. But
the interviewer’s skill level” is lacking. “Do you see this uneven
playing field we’ve created?”

“We think skill level will equate to job performance,”
she said. “That rules out people who are unskilled, or under-skilled, who
you could train, and they would turn out to be great employees.”

Instead, Quinn said, managers need to get the candidate to relax
and open up, then frame their questions carefully so they can ascertain whether
an applicant also has the motivation and the passion for a job.

Start with Chit-Chat

At the start of the interview, she said, it’s important to make
small talk.

“Get their guard down,” Quinn said. “Offer them a
beverage. Listen to them. Chit chat. Smile. Create an environment in which
people start to talk. You get them talking and sharing, and maybe you get

Quinn said many managers tend to rely on what she called
“behavior-based” interviewing, which includes questions that set the
applicant up for success and don’t challenge him.

For instance, if a manager wants to assess how motivated a candidate
is, she said, a behavior-based approach might be to ask: “Tell me about a
time when you went above and beyond to satisfy a customer.”

“What kind of answer are they going to give?” Quinn
asked. “I’ve given them an opportunity to brag about something. I’ve asked
for happy-ending success stories.”

Instead, she suggested using what she calls a
“motivation-based” approach to interviewing. For instance, ask the
candidate to describe how he handled an irate customer.

“This time, we put in an obstacle,” she said.
“This … can reveal whether someone is self-motivated.”

Motivation-based interviewing, she said, takes an applicant’s
skills into account, but goes further by trying to gauge the candidate’s
attitude and passions—traits common to high performers.

“Employers can’t change a person’s attitude,” she
said. “Eighty percent of one’s attitude is [set] by age 7.”

When trying to assess a candidate’s strengths and weaknesses,
she said, a behavior-based interviewer asks the applicant to list some
weaknesses. The answer to the question is unlikely to give the interviewer much
information, she said, because most applicants will give banal responses like
“I work too hard,” or “I care too much.”

Instead, she suggested, ask the candidate to describe the two
areas on his last performance evaluation where he scored the lowest.

“When you ask them for something’s that’s been documented,
there’s a difference in how they answer,” she said.

And no matter how a candidate answers a questions, she warned,
“even if it’s a shocker, I want you to smile and nod.”

“The fastest way to clam up [an applicant] is to show
negative judgment to one of their answers,” she said. “They will
adjust, amend and change their answers based on your reaction. If you relate to
a complainer, what do they do? They complain more. You want the [potential] bad
hires to be running their mouths during the interview process.”

you unhappy with your current recruiting processes? How do you make sure you
are attracting and selecting the best possible candidates for the position?
Converge HR Solutions offers a wide range of HR services, including a full
service recruitment process. Our team of experts is ready to help grow your
company, starting with the right people. To browse our services, visit Contact us directly at or 610-296-8550.

Article source:


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign Up for Our Monthly Newsletter

white converge hr logo

Reducing time spent on HR operations

Allowing you to focus on growing your business


1055 Westlakes DR, Suite 300, Berwyn, PA 19312

Skip to content